The Ten Commandments; the Ethos of God, or the Edict of Man? Including scratch-pad tablet for thoughtful comments
71The Ten Commandments of YAHWEH, our God as known in the Old Testament:
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS
- THE ETHOS OF GOD
-
given by Him according to His infinite wisdom, to GUIDE humankind away from self-destruction;
or an
- EDICT of MAN
-
invented for the CONTROL of civilization?
...
Definitions from: www.Wiktionary.org
Ethos: The character or fundamental values of a person, people, culture, or movement.
Edict: A proclamation of law or other authoritative command
...
![]() | Amazon Price: $3.48 List Price: $7.00 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $22.80 List Price: $25.95 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $3.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $8.95 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $7.50 |
Amazon Price: $11.93 List Price: $19.99 | |
![]() | Amazon Price: $17.00 List Price: $26.98 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $31.08 List Price: $49.99 |
Starting from scratch?
The Ten Commandments summarized:
1. People suggest all the time that Religion was developed by man (surreptitiously or not), specifically for the purpose of CONTROLLING the masses, as civilization developed.
2. Well, could not that same argument in some respect befit the purposes of our Creator?
a Does GOD not want to control us or, to be more congenial and respectful - to LEAD us and protect us (certainly enough so that we do not literally self-destruct through folly, vice, or scurrilous and dangerous temptation). Would one not hope that his chosen faith would at LEAST have these values?
b Or, does GOD not want to control us at all, but rather just let us run free and see how well we do, given His Providence, our circumstance, and our use of our blessed wherewithal which He bestowed upon us at birth?
c Or, could there be a figurative middle-ground, where GOD grants and bestows upon us an absolute and never-ending FREE-AGENCY (i.e.: our own wills), tempering us with our own unique wherewithal’s through His never-ending Grace and vested interest?
i. Wills which, through the determined mastery of our OWN agency , MUST anneal our fledgling spirits, to obtain the rightful Dominion we have been given in order to progress and rise above every adversity and challenge.
ii. Our spirits then must grow in their Dominion, upon a firm foundation, and develop the Power necessary to bridle our tongues and subject our flesh to the desires and choices of our own bestowed wills, which were gifted unto us unselfishly.
iii. Sensibly then, our wills can then be diligently aligned and positioned as ONE with His.
iv. Or, our wills can be NOT thus prudently aligned, and will therefore be considered of a foreign variety unbeknownst to the Gatekeeper, of a spotted, incomplete, and unwanted design orientation, indeed not of God’s own, according to His Word.
v. Could this not be so, while He reserves HIS Sovereignty by giving us RULES to live by - for us each to ultimately be Judged with Mercy AND Justice?
· Judged with an optional advocate Saviour designate - One who can be enlisted as our Redeemer, according to His Word.
· Then rewarded, or sentenced, according to the RULES we have ALL been given?
3. Of course, if we choose NOT to obey or, to be more congenial - to OBSERVE (since we ARE free to choose the thoughts we entertain - and the acts we do) The Ten Commandments, would we not through this abandonment be foolish? Would we not also INEVITABLY self-destruct from such a foolish decision, given our resultant reliance upon wisdom less sagacious, indeed our resultant reliance upon wisdom certainly less than infinite?
4. Does not a faith which espouses the tenets of God, and His Son, and His Holy Ghost witness the Majesty, Fairness and Love of a Supreme Creator? Does it not witness a Heavenly Father who wants us to Believe in Him, Believe in His Son, Believe in His Holy Ghost, and Believe that we can return to Him, treasured as His children, even a peculiar children, zealous of good works? Even so, as we veritably each develop as unique individuals, we have a place reserved in His Kingdom, which He has prepared for us, according to His Word, if we so incline ourselves.
5. Conversely, does not the assumed notion that these venerable Ten Commandments, recorded in ages past, were the concoction of man, likely invoked as a convenient necessity or a pompous ploy, which therefore because of this, brings about, through dissension, the terrible discord and warring amongst people, the unreasonable and unrelenting controversy amongst scholars, the troubles and plagues of man, and no doubt - abandonment - or change? (God Forbid.)
Which is best, and are there any other ways to live a life with purpose - and without torment, given the WITNESS, and knowledge of the singularity of a precious mortality linked in sequence with the eternal nature of one’s spirit?
...
Relevant Scripture:
¶ “And, behold, a certain lawyer stood up, and tempted him, saying, Master, what shall I do to inherit eternal life? He said unto him, What is written in the law? how readest thou? And he answering said, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind; and thy neighbour as thyself. And he said unto him, Thou hast answered right: this do, and thou shalt live.”
http://scriptures.lds.org/en/luke/10/25-28#25
...
Bible Dictionary; Jehovah
The covenant or proper name of the God of Israel. It denotes the “Unchangeable One,” “the eternal I AM” (Ex. 6: 3; Ps. 83: 18; Isa. 12: 2; Isa. 26: 4). The original pronunciation of this name has possibly been lost, as the Jews, in reading, never mentioned it, but substituted one of the other names of God, usually Adonai. Probably it was pronounced Jahveh, or Yahveh. In the KJV, the Jewish custom has been followed, and the name is generally denoted by LORD or GOD, printed in small capitals.
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (3)
- Funny
- Awesome (4)
- Beautiful (1)
- Interesting (1)
CommentsLoading...
Great hub Timothy. Coming soon- THE SECOND TEN COMMANDMENTS! God didn't want to confuse those folks who had just invented fire. But He'll get back to us! Great hub!
enjoyed the hub nice to see god's name referred to.,
OUTSTANDING, I REALLY ENJOYED READING YOUR HUB, THANKS...
Fantastic hub. Makes sense to me that we have free-will. God didn´t make us as robots., but He did give us the bible like a book of instructions for a happy life.
Amazed to see such a good reference to the name Jehovah. Also makes sense to me. Everyone else has a proper name, why not God?.
God bless you Timothy!
Hi! Timothy Good Hub! I like the Ten Commandments Summarized.
Hi Timothy. This was such an interesting hub that I just have to comment. Your question of whether the 10 Commandments are from God or man is very intriguing. And your development of your arguments that lead to deeper questions, are fascinating.
My questions and comments are very sincere. I have trouble clearly understanding you in some areas and so have made these comments:
1. Religion is the organization of people around a set of beliefs in a supreme being. Many religions have become so full of rules and traditions that the religion no longer resembles the initial tenets of the belief. So some people may be quite right that religions were developed to include rules made to control the masses. And, frankly, I doubt this happened surreptitiously.
2. If we accept that God was (would be) willing to guide us by subterfuge instead of divinely, then we suggest he is not pure love and truth.
3. God does not “want to control us” . He wants us to choose and commit to following him. To learn about him and thereby, know how to lead our lives according to the 10 Commandments or the 1 Commandment stated by Jesus.
4. God tempers us (just as gold is tempered/refined to make it pure) through trials and afflictions, in order for us to learn Patience, and patience strengthens us and shows us our true Character, which in turn shows us that not only have we prevailed through trials but that our Hope is certain, we can have faith in our hope and certainty in God’s love and never ending care.
5. We will not be judged according to God’s “rules” and we will not be judged according to what we do, have done, or not done and will not do. We will not be judged and then sentenced “according to the rules we have been given”, we will be judged by the degree to which we have followed God on a day-by-day basis.
6. This will direct us to different areas of responsibility in heaven. Our sentence of heaven or hell is based on our Salvation by our belief that Jesus is the son of God and knowing that through him (his suffering and death for us) we are guaranteed a place in heaven. I believe that God gives everyone a chance to be redeemed. But those who choose to live through eternity on their own power, will be given the opportunity to do so. Without God. And that is hell.
7. I don’t think we “veritably” develop as “unique” individuals, so much as we inevitably develop as “uniquely His”, as opposed to those who do not choose to come to God.
Are we thinking along the same lines but just saying things a little differently? Or, have I misunderstood your excellent comments and questions?
Thank you. And I wish you continued success in your writing.










![The Ten Commandments (Two-Disc Special Edition) [Blu-ray]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51mf90xse8L._SL75_.jpg)

















RevLady Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago
Hi TD,
In answer to the question, the ethos of God is preferred. For me, God's way is always best.
Great hub and I appreciated the edict - ethos -comparison.
Many blessings,
Forever His,